Lessons from the Moon

Let me start with a little story. When I was in the 3rd grade, I was introduced to Project Based Learning. At the time, I’m not sure Ms. Merano knew what that was, but the assignment had all the hallmarks: an entry document, explaining that we were going to be authors, a time frame for the project, a choice of what we could write about, and a competition component, which meant we would have an authentic audience. 

We were asked to write and publish our own book. The very thought of this project brings back all the joy and excitement I felt on that day. As a young boy, I was always creating stories and having adventures with my imaginary friends. The idea of me being able to publish a book seemed like something out of a dream. 

This was the first time in my educational career that I was excited to do homework. I remember brainstorming idea after idea, until I was finally touched by a muse. My story was going to be about the day the Moon stopped appearing in the sky. The story was called, “The Man on the Moon Has the Flu.” And if you don’t mind me saying so, it was an amazing piece of art!! This was the mid 80’s, so we had to publish books the old fashioned way, with construction paper and crayons!! 

Of course, wasting school supplies was unacceptable in my home and at school. I really wanted this book to look good, so I wrote the book in pencil. I have always struggled with grammar and spelling, so the use of the pencil would make it easier for me to correct my mistakes and keep my book looking neat.

It is at this point that my introduction to PBL fell off the rails. First, I want to make it clear that I’m not bashing Ms. Moreno. If anything, my issue is with the professional development that she received on this project. You see, to this day, some 34 years after writing my story about the Man on the Moon, I have no idea what grade I received. However, I am very aware of the fact that I failed the project. My story, even though Ms. Moreno said in her own words was “wonderful,” never got to be viewed by an authentic audience. Ms. Moreno informed me that my story could not be reviewed to become an actual book because it needed to written in pen and not pencil. As you can imagine, this was heart breaking to an 8 year old and unfortunately put an end to my creative writing. 

After all this time, I finally have the lessons I was supposed to learn from this project. 

Lesson 1: While your students are working for a grade, the teacher is working to make the student successful. 

Lesson 2: The power of the conference. Conferencing with your students, either in a  small group or one-on-one setting, provides the real world guidance that can get their project to an authentic audience. 


Lesson 3: Expose the details. It’s not enough to say, "I explained the assignment” or “I put that in the entry document.”  As a teacher you need to be the tour guide of the details that lead to success. 


Remember to serve and learn,

Torres

Twitter: @mrserveandlearn

Comments

Popular Posts